Honest comparison — November 2026 · written by the MailSimple team (yes, we're biased — but the numbers are checkable)
In one sentence: PurelyMail is unbeatable on raw price ($10/yr USD) but expects you to configure everything yourself — DNS, clients, migration. MailSimple costs $24–99/yr CAD and does the technical work for you, hosted in Canada, with human support in English or French.
If that's you: PurelyMail is a genuinely good service, we won't pretend otherwise. It's part of what inspired us.
| PurelyMail | MailSimple | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | US$10/yr (soft limits) | $24 – $49 – $99/yr CAD |
| Mailboxes / domains | Unlimited | Unlimited |
| DNS setup | Manual, by you | Automatic (Cloudflare) or assisted |
| Calendar + contacts + files | No | Included |
| Webmail | Basic | Full-featured, Gmail-style |
| Migration from Gmail/Outlook | DIY tool | Concierge — done for you |
| Hosting | United States | Canada |
| Support | English, minimalist | EN + FR, human |
| Billing | USD | CAD |
Verdict: price isn't the real question — the difference works out to about a dollar a month. The real question: do you want to administer your email, or just use it?
Why not just take the cheapest option? Because your email is mission-critical. One lost weekend debugging DNS costs more than a decade of price difference.
Can I migrate from PurelyMail to MailSimple? Yes — standard IMAP import, and our migration concierge can handle it for you.